As states increasingly roll out mandates requiring businesses to offer retirement plans, a dilemma emerges for both employers and employees. While these mandates are designed to bolster the long-term financial security of workers, they also present challenges, particularly for small businesses. In this article, we detail the state mandate dilemma, examining the complexities of balancing employee benefits with the affordability constraints that these mandates may impose. 

Learn how Asure makes it easy to offer a 401(k) to help you attract and retain top talent. 

The Rising Tide of State Mandates 

State mandates requiring businesses, regardless of size, to provide retirement plans have become a prevailing trend. Motivated by the need to address gaps in traditional retirement systems and ensure financial well-being for aging populations, these mandates aim to create a more inclusive retirement landscape. However, the implementation of such mandates is not without its challenges, especially for small businesses with limited resources. 

The Challenge of Affordability 

For small businesses, affordability is a central concern when it comes to implementing state-mandated retirement plans. While the goal is to provide valuable benefits to employees, the financial burden associated with compliance can be significant. Automatic deductions and contribution requirements may strain the budgets of both employers and employees, raising questions about the practicality of these mandates. 

Impact on Employees 

While the intent behind state mandates is undoubtedly positive – ensuring that employees have access to retirement savings – the potential impact on individual workers must be carefully considered. Automatic deductions from post-tax income, as mandated by some state programs, can result in a more substantial financial impact than anticipated. This poses a dilemma for employees who may face the challenge of balancing their immediate financial needs with long-term retirement planning. 

Striking the Right Balance 

Balancing the scales between providing valuable benefits and maintaining affordability is the key to navigating the state mandate dilemma. Small businesses, while committed to the well-being of their employees, must carefully assess the implications of these mandates on both their financial health and that of their workforce. Striking the right balance involves exploring options that align with the regulatory requirements while mitigating the potential negative effects on employees’ take-home pay. 

Seeking Affordable Solutions 

To address the affordability challenge posed by state mandates, small business owners can explore affordable retirement plan options. Engaging with financial professionals and retirement plan experts can provide insights into alternative solutions that meet regulatory requirements without imposing an undue financial burden. This may include exploring retirement plan structures that offer flexibility and cost-effectiveness. 

The Road Ahead 

Navigating the state mandate dilemma requires a nuanced approach that considers both the well-being of employees and the financial realities of small businesses. While the intent behind these mandates is commendable, the road ahead involves ongoing dialogue, collaboration, and a commitment to finding solutions that ensure the sustainability of retirement benefits without jeopardizing affordability. 


The state mandate dilemma underscores the complexities inherent in balancing employee benefits with affordability for small businesses. As the landscape continues to evolve, finding innovative and cost-effective solutions becomes imperative. By actively engaging with employees, seeking expert guidance, and exploring alternative retirement plan structures, small businesses can navigate this dilemma and contribute to a future where retirement benefits are both inclusive and financially sustainable. 

Learn how Asure makes it easy to offer a 401(k) to help you attract and retain top talent. 

Unlock your growth potential

Talk with one of experts to explore how Asure can help you reduce administrative burdens and focus on growth.