A hiring decision holds up under scrutiny when you can show, in writing, that it was based on job-related qualifications. If a candidate you passed over later files a discrimination charge, the EEOC typically asks the employer for a position statement backed by supporting documents, and it warns that an advocacy statement with no documentary evidence may lead it to conclude the employer has no evidence for its defense (EEOC). Records made at the time of the decision are that evidence; a recollection of an interview months later is not.
Here is what that paper trail should include, how long to keep it, and what changes when an applicant tracking system or an AI-assisted screening tool is part of your process.
What to Keep for Every Hiring Decision
- Keep the job posting or description used at the time, including the specific qualifications and requirements it listed.
- Keep interview notes that reference those stated qualifications, not general impressions of the candidate.
- Keep a scoring rubric or evaluation sheet, if your process uses one, completed the same way for every candidate in that pool.
- Keep a record of every candidate who applied or was considered for the role, not only the one you hired.
- Keep the specific, job-related reason you passed over each other candidate, written down at the time of the decision, not reconstructed later.
- If a background check from a screening company played a part in a decision not to hire, keep copies of the stand-alone Fair Credit Reporting Act disclosure, the candidate’s written authorization, and the pre-adverse action and adverse action notices you sent, per the Federal Trade Commission.
Tie the Decision to the Job, Not the Person
A rubric only protects you if every interviewer follows it the same way. Ask each candidate for a given role the same core questions, score the answers against the same job-related criteria, and write the reasoning in terms of the qualification. “Five years running payroll for a multi-location employer” is a defensible note. “Didn’t seem like the right fit for our team” is not, because it gives nothing to test against the job requirements and everything to test against age, pregnancy, national origin, or another protected characteristic as the real reason.
Train managers to leave a candidate’s age, health, family plans, accent, or appearance out of the file entirely. None of it belongs there, whether or not it actually influenced the decision, because its presence alone invites a very different line of questioning later. If you collect medical information after a conditional job offer, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requires keeping it on separate forms, in a separate medical file, treated as a confidential medical record under 29 CFR 1630.14.
How Long to Keep Hiring Records
Under the EEOC’s recordkeeping regulation, 29 CFR Part 1602, private employers must retain personnel and employment records, including applications and records tied to hiring decisions, for one year from the date the record was made or the date of the personnel action, whichever is later. If a discrimination charge is filed, that clock extends: records related to the charge must be kept until the charge, or any resulting court action, reaches final disposition, which can mean several years (29 CFR 1602.14). Separately, once a claim is reasonably anticipated, for example after a demand letter, preserve the related electronic records too, because federal courts can impose measures when such information is lost (Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(e)). The Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) has a parallel rule, 29 CFR 1627.3, that requires keeping job applications, resumes, and records of any refusal to hire for one year from the date of the personnel action.
The federal laws behind these rules come with coverage thresholds. Title VII, the ADA, and the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) apply to private employers with 15 or more employees who worked for at least 20 calendar weeks in the current or prior year, and the ADEA applies at 20 or more. The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act also applies at 15 or more employees, and virtually all employers are covered by the Equal Pay Act. State laws often reach smaller employers. California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act, for example, applies to employers of five or more.
Some states set longer retention periods. In California, employers must keep employment records, including automated-decision data, for at least four years. If you hire across more than one state, the safer practice is to apply the longest period that touches any location where you hire, rather than tracking a different clock for each one.
When an ATS or AI-Assisted Screening Tool Is Part of the Process
An applicant tracking system or an AI-assisted resume screen does not change what a discrimination claim turns on: whether the decision was based on job-related qualifications. It adds two things you now need to document. First, what the tool actually screened for, and whether a person reviewed its output before any candidate was rejected or advanced. Second, that a specific person remains accountable for the final call, not the software.
The federal legal anchor is Title VII’s disparate-impact provision, 42 U.S.C. 2000e-2(k). Once an applicant shows that a particular hiring practice causes a disparate impact on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin, the practice is unlawful unless the employer demonstrates that it is job related for the position and consistent with business necessity. The statute covers any particular employment practice, which includes a software screen as much as a human one. The statute is unchanged as of October 2026, although Executive Order 14281 (April 2025) directs federal agencies to deprioritize disparate-impact enforcement; applicants can still bring these claims in court.
As of October 2026, scrutiny of AI-assisted hiring and screening tools comes from state and local laws written specifically for them and from plaintiff-side litigation. For example:
- New York City’s Local Law 144 bars employers and employment agencies from using an automated employment decision tool unless the tool has had a bias audit within one year of its use, information about the audit is publicly available, and candidates or employees have received the required notice, per the NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection.
- California Civil Rights Council regulations that took effect October 1, 2025 make clear that an automated-decision system can violate state law if it harms applicants or employees based on a protected characteristic, and that an automated assessment eliciting information about a disability may be an unlawful medical inquiry, per the California Civil Rights Department.
- Illinois amended its Human Rights Act, effective January 1, 2026, to make it a civil rights violation for an employer to use artificial intelligence in recruitment or hiring in a way that has the effect of discriminating on the basis of a protected class, or to fail to give notice that it uses artificial intelligence for those decisions (Public Act 103-0804). The Illinois Department of Human Rights had not adopted rules on the timing and form of that notice as of October 2026.
- Job applicants have brought discrimination lawsuits in federal court challenging how AI screening tools score, rank, and screen applicants.
That makes the documentation habit matter more, not less, when a tool is involved. Keep the criteria the tool applied, keep the underlying resumes and scores alongside the reviewer’s notes, and be ready to show that a human decision-maker weighed qualifications rather than deferring to a score.
Where This Documentation Should Live
Hiring records scattered across email threads, shared drives, and a hiring manager’s notebook are hard to produce completely, and consistently, once a claim arrives months after the fact. They are also easy to lose before the retention periods described above run out. Asure HR Compliance gives you on-demand access to certified HR professionals who can help you build a consistent documentation practice for hiring, without adding to your own headcount.
Asure Recruiting keeps applicant information and hiring activity centralized and time-stamped in one system. Every hiring action is tracked with a date and time, which gives you a clear record of who applied and how decisions were made. Asure Recruiting also includes configurable applicant workflows, a central review dashboard, and unlimited applicant storage. Because it connects directly into AsureCentral, a hired candidate flows into onboarding without re-entry.
Related Questions
What records should an employer keep to defend against a hiring discrimination claim?
The job posting and its stated qualifications, interview notes and scoring tied to those qualifications, a record of every candidate considered, and a specific, job-related reason for each candidate you did not advance.
How long must hiring records be retained?
At least one year from the date the record was made or the personnel action occurred, whichever is later, under 29 CFR Part 1602, and longer if a discrimination charge is filed. Some states require more. California requires employment records, including automated-decision data, to be kept for at least four years.
Does an ATS or AI screening tool change what needs to be documented?
It adds to the requirement rather than replacing it. Keep the criteria the tool used and evidence that a person reviewed its output before the hiring decision was final.
Which employers are covered by federal hiring discrimination laws?
Title VII, the ADA, GINA, and the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act cover private employers with 15 or more employees, the ADEA covers employers with 20 or more, and the Equal Pay Act covers virtually all employers. Many state laws reach smaller employers. California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act, for example, applies to employers of five or more.
Which laws address AI tools used in hiring?
As of October 2026, examples include New York City’s Local Law 144 (bias audits, public audit information, and candidate notice), California Civil Rights Council regulations effective October 1, 2025, and an Illinois Human Rights Act amendment effective January 1, 2026. At the federal level, Title VII’s disparate-impact standard applies to any hiring practice, including a software screen.
Consistent hiring documentation is far easier to build before a claim shows up than after. Practical Steps for Building an EEO Policy covers the policy side of this work, and Asure HR Compliance can help put the day-to-day documentation habits behind it.
